COLUMN 104, APRIL 1, 2004
(Copyright © 2004 The Blacklisted Journalist)
BRIAN WILSON'S 'SMILE'
[JULES SIEGEL can be contacted at Apdo. 1764 77501-Cancun Q. Roo Mexico. His website can be found at http://www.madlaughter.com . Another of his websites, listed as
"Newsroom-l, news and issues for journalists" can be accesses at
I was very
moved Saturday morning to learn that Brian Wilson received a five-minute
standing ovation at the conclusion of his Smile performance. In
"Holy Pop Relic" http://slate.msn.com/id/2095025/
, Jeff Turrentine mentions my role in the saga of Brian Wilson's Smile
Turrentine correctly reports that the Saturday Evening Post killed my
story, it was later published in Cheetah magazine, October, 1967, as Goodbye
Surfing, Hello God!---the Religious Conversion of the Beach Boys.
It's been anthologized in at least four books, most recently in Library of
America's Writing Los Angeles.
false humility, I can say that I was one of the people who invented rock
journalism. Journalists such as Al Aronowitz, Richard Goldstein and I were among
the first to write about rock in mainstream media without being condescending or
demeaning. Nonetheless, I never thought of Goodbye Surfing, Hello God! as
rock journalism. It was a pretty far-out piece even for regular journalism at
the time. I don't think many celebrity pieces before or since have ever gotten
that close to a subject and been written about it.
Brian was quite upset about it. I heard that the Beach Boys were still complaining about it a few years later in Tom Nolan's Rolling Stone interview. Maybe now he's got some more distance on it and can see that Goodbye Surfing, Hello God! was a principal force in creating the myth of
Writers were forbidden to use the first person singular at the Saturday Evening Post
know that others did write about it at the time, but some of them talked to me
first. Other than David Oppenheimer, I was the only one in the major media who
took Brian seriously, and even David talked with me at great length while he was
making his documentary.
In reading over
my story 37 years later, I see some rather awkward moments. At the time, Saturday
Evening Post writers did not usually mention themselves in stories. I wanted
to do this story exactly as I would have written a short story or a segment of a
novel. In order to get around my adherence to the convention of impersonality, I
had to describe myself as a "Saturday Evening Post" writer and
a "friend." Both were true, but these days I would just use
"I" or "me." Some of the writing is a little too
self-consciously jazzy, but I was young then.
minor flaws, I'm still very happy with the story, and I am even happier that
Brian has finally achieved his dream. He was a giant then and he is a giant now.
All of us who struggle against the mainstream currents can take heart in this
outcome. For once, a good guy wins. God bless Brian Wilson! God bless all
artists who try and fail, and try again and fail again, ad infinitum, but never
Goodbye Surfing, Hello God! can be found online at http://www.cafecancun.com/bookarts/wilson.htm ##
ON THIS 40TH ANNIVERSARY OF BEATLEMANIA!
A 615-PAGE PAPERBACK THAT TELLS YOU MORE ABOUT BOB DYLAN AND THE BEATLES THAN ANY OTHER WRITER CAN TELL YOU, BECAUSE THE AUTHOR WAS THERE AND NO OTHER WRITER WAS
YOU CAN ORDER 'BOB DYLAN AND THE BEATLES' FROM 1ST BOOKS LIBRARY AT www.1stbooks.com AT $17 A COPY OR YOU CAN PURCHASE THE BOOK FROM BOOKSELLERS AT $25.95 A COPY
0R, IF YOU WANT A COPY THAT'S NUMBERED AND SIGNED, SEND A UNITED STATES POSTAL MONEY ORDER FOR $17 PLUS $3 FOR SHIPPING AND HANDLING TO THE BLACKLISTED JOURNALIST, BOX 964, ELIZABETH, N.J. 07208
OR, IF YOU WANT THE BOOK SHIPPED TO YOU VIA PRIORITY MAIL, SEND A MONEY ORDER FOR $25
NO CHECKS ACCEPTED!
CLICK HERE TO GET TO INDEX OF COLUMN 104
CLICK HERE TO GET TO INDEX OF COLUMNS
Blacklisted Journalist can be contacted at P.O.Box 964, Elizabeth, NJ 07208-0964
The Blacklisted Journalist's E-Mail Address:
THE BLACKLISTED JOURNALIST IS A SERVICE MARK OF AL ARONOWITZ